Altier Rare Coins Review

July 12, 2023
Written by Peter Anderson

Altier Rare Coins is a well-established rare coin and precious metals company based in South Florida. Founded by Justin Altier, the company specializes in purchasing bullion, currency, and jewelry such as gold and silver bullion bars, precious metal rounds, and rare collectible currency.

Altier Rare Coins utilizes the Sheldon Scale for grading precious metals and coins to ensure transparency and authenticity. They cater to both in-house and mail-in clients, offering a 72-hour acceptance period for purchase offers. Accepted offers can be paid through check, bank wire, or PayPal.

As an authorized dealer for reputable organizations like PCGS, PMG, NGC, and CAC, Altier Rare Coins has garnered positive reviews for their professionalism, expertise, and fair pricing. They provide comprehensive customer service via phone and email support while also offering a FAQ section on their website for easy reference.

In addition to buying estate jewelry and performing estate appraisals to maximize value, Altier Rare Coins focuses on assisting collectors, investors, and individuals seeking to buy or sell coins in increasing their profits.

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are from sponsors. The list below is an honest review gathered from thorough research, experience, and consumer-based feedback. 

Before we get started with this review:

We understand that choosing a company to invest with is an extremely important financial choice; good news for you, we have done all the research and digging in this field for years.

That being said, through our rigorous review process, we have compiled a list of our 5 top gold investment companies for 2022.

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Check if Altier Rare Coins made our top 5 list in 2023! 


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation by clicking below:

Altier Rare Coins Products and Services

Altier Rare Coins offers a wide range of products and services, including the buying and selling of bullion, currency, jewelry, as well as estate appraisals, all aimed at helping collectors and investors maximize their profits.

The company is known for its expertise in altier rare coins valuation and authentication. They use the Sheldon Scale to grade precious metals and rare coins, ensuring accurate assessments of each item's condition.

When it comes to the purchasing process, Altier Rare Coins serves both in-house and mail-in clients. They provide a 72-hour acceptance period for purchase offers, allowing customers ample time to consider their options. For accepted offers, payment can be received via check, bank wire, or PayPal.

Customer testimonials highlight Altier Rare Coins' professionalism, knowledge, fair pricing, and quick responsiveness. The company's transparent coin grading is also appreciated by customers who value authenticity when buying or selling rare coins.

In addition to their buying and selling services for bullion, currency, and jewelry items such as watches, bracelets, necklaces, and rings; Altier Rare Coins also specializes in estate appraisals. Their experienced appraisers work diligently to help clients maximize the value of each item within their estate.

Altier Rare Coins provides a comprehensive range of services with a focus on assisting collectors and investors in maximizing their profits through fair valuations and reliable authentication processes.

Selling to Altier Rare Coins

When choosing to sell your items, Altier Rare Coins provides multiple payment options such as checks, bank wires, and PayPal.

After sending in your items for evaluation, one of their buyers will contact you with a purchase offer within 72 hours. If you accept the offer, Altier Rare Coins will send your payment within 24 hours of acceptance.

They offer different payment methods depending on your preference.

Checks are typically sent via USPS first-class mail on the same day the offer is accepted. For larger funds, a bank wire can be arranged, which may take up to 48 hours to show in your account. If you prefer a faster electronic payment method, PayPal payments are also available on the same day of acceptance.

It's important to note that while Altier Rare Coins does not charge for PayPal payments, there may be associated fees from PayPal.

Customer testimonials highlight that Altier Rare Coins provides a quick and responsive service during the selling process. They appreciate the company's professionalism and fair pricing when evaluating coins and precious metals. Altier Rare Coins also buys estate jewelry and performs appraisals to maximize its value.

When selling items to Altier Rare Coins, customers have various payment options available such as checks, bank wires, and PayPal. The company aims to provide fast and efficient service throughout the coin evaluation process and offers different methods for receiving payments based on individual preferences.


The customer feedback for Altier Rare Coins reflects a mix of positive and negative experiences, providing valuable insights into the company's reputation and service quality.

On Trustpilot, Altier Rare Coins has received an average rating of 2.8 out of 5 based on 8 reviews. While most reviewers praised Justin's professionalism, knowledge, and fair pricing, there appears to be only one negative review regarding a timing discrepancy with the store hours.

This suggests that some customers may have had issues with the accuracy of information provided by the company.

On Yelp, Altier Rare Coins has received an average rating of 4 out of 5 based on 5 reviews. Reviewers on this platform also commended Justin for his honesty, fairness in pricing, and quick responsiveness. Many customers consider Altier Rare Coins as their go-to financial company for precious metals.

While there are mixed reviews for Altier Rare Coins, the majority of customers seem satisfied with their experience.

The company's reputation is generally positive, with customers appreciating Justin's professionalism and fair pricing. However, it is worth noting that there have been some concerns raised about discrepancies in information provided by the company.

Nonetheless, Altier Rare Coins seems to prioritize customer satisfaction and aims to provide a reliable service in the rare coin industry.

Customer Service

Customer service at Altier Rare Coins is highly regarded, with customers appreciating the company's quick and responsive support, which contributes to a positive overall experience.

The company offers multiple communication channels for customers to reach out for assistance. Customers can contact Altier Rare Coins by phone at 954.580.3595 or via email at

These options allow for convenient and efficient communication between the company and its clients.

Response time is an important aspect of customer service, and Altier Rare Coins aims to provide timely assistance to their customers. Reviews suggest that the company responds promptly to inquiries and provides helpful information in a timely manner, ensuring that customers' needs are met efficiently.

Customers have expressed high levels of satisfaction with the support options provided by Altier Rare Coins. The company offers comprehensive customer service through phone and email support, allowing customers to choose their preferred method of communication.

Altier Rare Coins also has a FAQ section on their website, which provides quick solutions to common questions or concerns that customers may have. This resource allows customers to find answers independently without needing to reach out for assistance in many cases.

Altier Rare Coins' commitment to providing quick and responsive customer service contributes significantly to positive customer experiences.

The availability of various communication channels, prompt response times, multiple support options, and the inclusion of a FAQ section all contribute towards ensuring customer satisfaction throughout their interactions with the company.

Altier Rare Coins Pros

One notable advantage of Altier Rare Coins is its status as an authorized dealer for reputable companies, which reinforces its reputation and reliability in the precious metals industry. 

Being an authorized dealer for companies such as CAC, NGC, and PCGS further enhances Altier Rare Coins' credibility in the market. This affiliation indicates that the company adheres to strict standards and practices when it comes to grading and authenticating rare coins.

Altier Rare Coins' reputation is also bolstered by positive customer testimonials.

Clients have praised Justin Altier for his professionalism, knowledge, and fair pricing. These testimonials highlight the company's commitment to providing excellent customer service and ensuring customer satisfaction.

In terms of pricing, Altier Rare Coins offers a fair price for precious metals based on their grading system. The company uses the Sheldon Scale to grade precious metals and rare coins accurately. 

They have on-site numismatists who authenticate each coin before making an offer, ensuring transparency throughout the process.

Altier Rare Coins provides multiple payment options for accepted offers, including check, bank wire transfer, or PayPal. This flexibility allows customers to choose their preferred method of receiving payment conveniently.

Altier Rare Coins' reputation as an authorized dealer for reputable companies, fair pricing practices, thorough authentication process, diverse payment options, and positive customer testimonials contribute to its standing as a reliable choice in the precious metals industry.


Despite its strong reputation and positive customer testimonials, it is important to note some limitations of Altier Rare Coins. One major drawback is that the company does not offer a gold IRA account option.

This means that investors who are specifically looking for a gold IRA will need to seek out another financial institution.

Altier Rare Coins does not provide the option to purchase rare coins or precious metals on their website.

Their focus is solely on buying rare coins and metals from clients. If individuals are interested in purchasing precious metals, they will have to find a different precious metals dealer.

These limitations can be seen as significant downsides for individuals who are seeking comprehensive services that include both buying and selling rare coins or investing in a gold IRA. It may also be inconvenient for potential customers who want a one-stop shop for all their coin-related needs.

Despite these drawbacks, Altier Rare Coins still maintains a solid reputation and has received positive reviews from customers regarding their professionalism, knowledge, fair pricing, and quick service.

While Altier Rare Coins has many positive aspects and is well-regarded within the industry, it is important to consider the cons associated with their services. The absence of a gold IRA account option and the inability to purchase rare coins directly from the company's website may limit their appeal for certain types of investors or collectors seeking more comprehensive options.


Altier Rare Coins is a reputable company that specializes in buying and selling rare coins, bullion, and jewelry.

They offer a wide range of products and services, including the purchase of gold and silver bullion bars, precious metal rounds, and collectible currency.

With their use of the Sheldon Scale for grading precious metals and coins, they ensure transparency and authenticity. Altier Rare Coins has gained positive reviews for their professionalism, knowledge, fair pricing, and comprehensive customer service.

While they do not offer certain services like gold IRA accounts or rare coins for collection, they focus on helping collectors and investors increase their profits through buying and selling coins.

You can get a Complimentary Gold Investing Guide from the top gold investing company we recommend by clicking the button above. 

If you'd like a thorough review of the top 5 list, click here:

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Or, visit Altier Rare Coins below: