Bullion Shark Review

August 16, 2023
Written by Peter Anderson

Looking to invest in bullion, rare coins, or currency? Bullion Shark, a well-established bullion dealer based in Old Westbury, New York, may be just what you're looking for.

With their wide range of products and knowledgeable staff, they offer a comprehensive selection of coins including modern rare coins, classic rare coins, bullion, ancient coins, and shipwreck coins.

Opening an account with Bullion Shark brings benefits such as faster checkout, multiple shipping addresses, order history access, order tracking, and wish lists.

They provide free shipping on orders over $99 and have numismatic experts on staff. Although the company has mixed customer reviews—some praising their great service and unique coins while others mention discrepancies in weight and refund issues—it is recommended to do further research and start with a small purchase first.

Keep reading this article for more information about Bullion Shark's products and services.

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are from sponsors. The list below is an honest review gathered from thorough research, experience, and consumer-based feedback. 

Before we get started with this review:

We understand that choosing a company to invest with is an extremely important financial choice; good news for you, we have done all the research and digging in this field for years.

That being said, through our rigorous review process, we have compiled a list of our 5 top gold investment companies for 2022.

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Check if Bullion Shark made our top 5 list in 2023! 


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation by clicking below:

Bullion Shark Products

If you're an investor looking to diversify your portfolio, Bullion Shark has a wide range of products for you to choose from. They offer modern rare coins, classic rare coins, bullion, and even ancient and shipwreck coins.

In their Modern Rare Coins category, you'll find popular options like the 2022 Palladium Eagles, Silver Eagles, 2021-Present Morgan and Peace Dollars, and Gold Buffalo Coins.

For those interested in Classic Rare Coins, Bullion Shark offers Two Cent Pieces, Half Dollars, Quarters, Nickels, Half Cents, and more.

When it comes to bullion products, Bullion Shark has a variety of options available. You can find Silver bullion, gold bullion, platinum bullion, and even copper bullion.

If you're looking for unique coin options with historical significance or ties to famous shipwrecks, their Ancient and Shipwreck Coin collection includes Roman Coins, Greek Coins, Biblical Coins, and Shipwreck Coins.

Bullion Shark is known for its competitive pricing on their website. They also prioritize customer service by providing personal assistance from knowledgeable staff members.

Bullion Shark offers free shipping on orders over $99.

One aspect that sets Bullion Shark apart is their authenticity guarantee. With numismatic experts on staff, Bullion Shark ensures that all the products they sell are genuine and authentic.

So if you're in the market for investment-grade coins or precious metals, Bullion Shark provides a comprehensive selection of high-quality products along with fair pricing, personalized service, and a reliable shipping policy.

Opening an Account at Bullion Shark

Opening an account at Bullion Shark, you'll enjoy a faster checkout, multiple shipping addresses, access to your order history, real-time order tracking, and the convenience of creating a wish list for your favorite coins.

When it comes to purchasing coins with Bullion Shark, having an account offers several benefits that can enhance your overall buying experience.

  • One advantage of opening an account is the faster checkout process. 

This means that you won't have to spend unnecessary time entering your information every time you make a purchase. If you're someone who likes to ship coins to different addresses depending on the situation, having an account allows you to have multiple shipping addresses on file for added convenience.

  • Another great feature of opening an account is the ability to access your order history. 

This can be helpful when keeping track of which coins you already own and avoiding duplicates in future purchases. With real-time order tracking available through your account, you can easily monitor the progress of your shipment and know exactly when it will arrive at your doorstep.

  • Creating a wish list within your account allows you to keep track of potential coin purchases and quickly find them when you're ready to buy.

Opening an account at Bullion Shark provides numerous perks and advantages that can streamline the coin-buying process and enhance your overall shopping experience.

Bullion Shark Highlights

When you open an account at Bullion Shark, you'll have access to a range of benefits that enhance your coin-buying experience.

One of the key benefits is their knowledgeable staff. Bullion Shark prides itself on having numismatic experts on hand to assist customers with any questions they may have about selecting coins or placing them in a precious metals IRA.

Bullion Shark offers free shipping on all orders over $99. This is a significant benefit as it allows you to save money on shipping costs which can add up quickly when purchasing coins.

Another highlight of opening an account at Bullion Shark is their Auction section. While there are currently no upcoming auctions listed, this feature provides the opportunity for investors to find great deals or unique coins.

The company regularly updates their auction catalog until items are sold, so it's worth checking back often.

Opening an account at Bullion Shark offers several benefits including access to knowledgeable staff, free shipping on qualifying orders, and the opportunity to participate in their Auction section.

These features make buying coins from Bullion Shark a convenient and enjoyable experience for collectors and investors alike.

Returns & Exchanges

Experience a hassle-free shopping experience at Bullion Shark, where you can enjoy a 14-day return period to ensure your complete satisfaction with your purchase. 

The company's return policy is relatively standard for a precious metals dealer and aims to provide customers with fair options for returns and exchanges.

Here are some key points about Bullion Shark's return and exchange process:

  • Return Policy: Customers have 14 days from the date they receive their item to initiate a return. This gives you ample time to thoroughly inspect your purchase and decide if it meets your expectations.
  • Refund Process: If you need to make a return, simply contact Bullion Shark within the 14-day period either by email or phone. They'll guide you through the necessary steps to initiate the refund process.
  • Customer Satisfaction: Bullion Shark strives for customer satisfaction, which is why they offer this generous return policy. They want you to be completely happy with your investment in bullion, rare coins, or currency.
  • Exchange Options: In addition to refunds, Bullion Shark also provides exchange options. If you prefer an alternative product or would like to explore other investment opportunities within their wide range of offerings, they're happy to assist.
  • Return Shipping: It's important to note that while the company offers returns and exchanges, shipping and handling charges are non-refundable. Therefore, it's advisable to carefully consider your purchase before initiating a return.

With these policies in place, Bullion Shark aims to provide customers with peace of mind when making their investment decisions.

Customer Reviews

Customers have had a wide range of experiences with Bullion Shark, leaving both positive and negative reviews that showcase the company's strengths and weaknesses.

Some customers have praised the customer service provided by Bullion Shark, mentioning that their staff is knowledgeable and provides great service. They have also mentioned that the company offers unique coins that are hard to find elsewhere, making them stand out in the market.

In terms of product quality, there have been a few negative reviews regarding discrepancies in weight or receiving different coins than those advertised on the website.

These instances raise concerns about accuracy and attention to detail.

On the other hand, customers have generally been satisfied with their shipping experience when purchasing from Bullion Shark. Many mention fast and easy shipping processes, which is an important factor for those investing in bullion or rare coins.

Pricing comparison is another aspect highlighted by customers.

While some mention clear pricing on the website and value for money, others suggest comparing prices with other dealers before making a purchase to ensure competitiveness.

Overall customer satisfaction seems to vary depending on individual experiences.

It is recommended to do further research and consider making a small purchase first to assess factors such as product quality, accuracy in weights, refunds process, and overall satisfaction with Bullion Shark's services.

Bullion Shark: Pros and Cons

When it comes to customer service, opening an account with Bullion Shark offers several benefits such as faster shipping, multiple shipping addresses, and order tracking.

This can enhance your overall purchasing experience.

In terms of pricing, Bullion Shark stands out by providing clear and straightforward prices on their website.

You don't need to contact customer service for pricing details, making it convenient for investors to plan their purchases.

When it comes to reliability, Bullion Shark has a fair return and exchange policy that instills confidence in customers. They practice fairness in their transactions, ensuring a positive buying experience.

Bullion Shark offers a comprehensive selection of coins for investors. Whether you're looking for modern rare coins or classic rare coins, they have a wide range of options available.

Some customers have even mentioned finding unique coins that are not easily obtainable elsewhere.

On the other hand, there are some downsides to consider.

Bullion Shark lacks trusted recognitions from reputable financial companies, which might raise concerns about their credibility compared to other dealers.

Although they have received mixed reviews overall, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the company's transparency and difficulty obtaining refunds.

Considering these pros and cons alongside further research will help you make an informed decision when considering purchasing from Bullion Shark.


Bullion Shark offers a wide range of products and services for bullion enthusiasts. They have a comprehensive selection of coins, and their staff is knowledgeable.

They also offer free shipping on orders over $99, aiming to provide a convenient and reliable shopping experience.

It is important to note the mixed customer reviews. Some customers have mentioned discrepancies in weight and issues with refunds.

That's why, it is recommended to conduct further research and start with a small purchase to ensure satisfaction.

Bullion Shark presents potential benefits, but it also carries potential risks for customers.

You can get a Complimentary Gold Investing Guide from the top gold investing company we recommend by clicking the button above. 

If you'd like a thorough review of the top 5 list, click here:

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Or, visit Bullion Shark below: