First Fidelity Reserve Review

August 19, 2023
Written by Peter Anderson

Looking to invest in precious metals? Look no further than First Fidelity Reserve. With over 25 years of experience, this trusted company specializes in buying and selling gold and silver coins, including rare coins.

Their exceptional service and educational materials ensure that you make informed investment decisions.

Offering a wide range of gold and silver products, including government-issued coins like American Gold Eagles and Canadian Maple Leafs, they have an extensive inventory to fulfill orders promptly.

Dr. Mike Fuljenz, an expert in the field, provides guidance to clients.

Not only does First Fidelity Reserve pay some of the highest prices for coins in the industry, but they also focus on historically important coins that can experience significant price increases.

Don't miss out on their options for collectors of rare coins as well as palladium and platinum options.

Discover why First Fidelity Reserve is a reputable company with a strong track record in the precious metals industry today!

Disclosure: Some of the links in this article are from sponsors. The list below is an honest review gathered from thorough research, experience, and consumer-based feedback. 

Before we get started with this review:

We understand that choosing a company to invest with is an extremely important financial choice; good news for you, we have done all the research and digging in this field for years.

That being said, through our rigorous review process, we have compiled a list of our 5 top gold investment companies for 2022.

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Check if First Fidelity Reserve made our top 5 list in 2023! 


Get a FREE Gold Investing Kit from our #1 recommendation by clicking below:

First Fidelity Reserve Company Information

If you're looking for a reputable and experienced company to buy rare and valuable coins, First Fidelity Reserve is the perfect choice. With over 30 years of serving tens of thousands of satisfied clients, they have established themselves as one of the largest and most respected dealers in the American marketplace.

Their extensive market presence allows them to provide quality service and competitive rates to their clients.

First Fidelity Reserve's commitment to customer service is evident through their knowledgeable staff of numismatic professionals who are dedicated to assisting clients with their investment needs.

They offer a wide range of educational resources, including free books, newspapers, and articles, to help investors stay informed about ongoing trends in the rare coin marketplace.

This shows their dedication to helping clients make informed decisions.

Throughout its history, First Fidelity Reserve has transacted over $480 million and served over 109,000 clients since 1988. Their longevity in the industry showcases their experience and expertise.

They maintain an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, ensuring that all transactions are confidential and private.

If you're seeking a trustworthy company with a strong market presence, exceptional customer service, and extensive educational resources, First Fidelity Reserve is an excellent choice for buying rare and valuable coins.

Why Choose First Fidelity Reserve?

With over 40 years of experience and a reputation as an industry expert, Dr. Mike Fuljenz and the team at First Fidelity offer clients a distinct advantage in making wise choices for their gold, silver, and rare coin investments.

Dr. Fuljenz's expertise in grading coins and his extensive knowledge of the market allow him to provide valuable guidance to clients.

One of the advantages of choosing First Fidelity Reserve is their track record of success.

The company has been serving clients for over 25 years and has transacted over $480 million while serving more than 109,000 clients since 1988. This demonstrates their commitment to providing superlative service.

Customer testimonials also speak highly of First Fidelity Reserve's services. Positive reviews mention excellent pricing, timely delivery, and sound advice from their knowledgeable team.

While there are some negative reviews mentioning difficulty reaching specific individuals or a high-pressure sales approach, it is important to note that research and due diligence are recommended before investing with any company.

In addition to their experienced team and positive customer feedback, First Fidelity Reserve offers gold market analysis to help investors make informed decisions. This analysis can be especially valuable during volatile times when market conditions may impact precious metals prices.

First Fidelity Reserve's advantages lie in their experienced team led by Dr. Mike Fuljenz, their track record of success, positive customer testimonials, and gold market analysis provided to clients.

These factors make them a reputable option for individuals looking to invest in gold, silver, or rare coins.

First Fidelity Reserve's Products

One can explore a wide range of gold and silver products at First Fidelity Reserve. They offer American Gold Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, rare coins, and more.

When it comes to gold coins, First Fidelity offers a full complement of American Gold Eagles in various denominations such as the 2022 $5, $10, $25, and $50 versions. They also have the 2022 1oz gold American Buffalo and the $3 Indian Princess coins.

In addition to these government-issued coins, they provide options like the Canadian Maple Leaf, Britannia, and Australian Kangaroo.

For those interested in silver products, First Fidelity Reserve has you covered with their offerings. They have the popular $1 American Silver Eagle coin along with the Kennedy Silver Half Dollar and Morgan Silver Dollar.

They also offer Buffalo Silver Rounds and other options like the Canadian Maple Leaf, Britannia, Australian Kangaroo, Austrian Philharmonic, and South African Krugerrand.

In addition to gold and silver bullion coins, First Fidelity Reserve also sells rare coins such as the 1908 $2.50 gold Indian coin and a variety of other gold Indian coins.

They offer specialty coins like those recovered from shipwrecks as well as palladium and platinum options for investors looking for alternative investment choices.

First Fidelity Reserve provides a diverse selection of investment options for individuals interested in precious metals. Whether you're interested in gold or silver bullion coins or collectible rare coins, they have something to suit your needs.


While past performance can't guarantee future results, First Fidelity Reserve's strategy focuses on historically important coins that have the potential for significant price increases.

Here are four key aspects of their strategy:

  1. Gold investment: First Fidelity Reserve emphasizes investing in gold as a way to diversify your portfolio and protect against inflation and market volatility. They believe that gold has historically maintained its value over time and can serve as a safe haven during uncertain economic conditions.
  2. Historical coins: The company recommends buying historically important coins, such as the Indian Head Quarter and Half Eagle coins, which possess unique characteristics that make them valuable to collectors. These coins have a higher probability of becoming rare in the future, leading to potential price appreciation.
  3. Timely fulfillment: To ensure customer satisfaction, First Fidelity Reserve maintains an extensive inventory of gold and silver products. This allows them to promptly fulfill orders and provide timely delivery to their clients.
  4. Expert guidance: Dr. Mike Fuljenz, an expert in rare coins and precious metals, provides guidance and expertise to clients at First Fidelity Reserve. His knowledge helps investors make informed decisions about their purchases and maximize their potential profits.

First Fidelity Reserve pays some of the highest prices for coins in the field, making it advantageous for sellers looking to get the best value for their investments.

First Fidelity Reserve's strategy combines historical significance, expert guidance, timely fulfillment, and high prices to offer investors a comprehensive approach to gold investment.

First Fidelity Reserve's Gold Expert

Renowned in the field of rare coins and precious metals, Dr. Michael Fuljenz is the trusted gold expert at First Fidelity Reserve. He captivates investors with his unparalleled knowledge and passion for maximizing their profits.

With over 60 awards to his name, Dr. Fuljenz's expertise extends beyond the realm of rare coins and precious metals. He provides market analysis, investment advice, and industry insights that are invaluable to clients seeking to navigate the complex world of gold investing.

Dr. Fuljenz's rare coin expertise sets him apart from other gold experts in the industry.

His extensive experience as a consultant to prestigious institutions such as the Federal Trade Commission and U.S. and Royal Canadian Mints has honed his ability to identify historically important coins that can experience dramatic price increases. This strategic approach ensures that clients at First Fidelity Reserve are able to make informed decisions when it comes to their investments.

Moreover, Dr. Fuljenz's commitment to consumer education shines through in his role as an educator at First Fidelity Reserve. He tirelessly provides clients with educational materials that empower them with the knowledge they need to make sound investment choices.

Dr. Michael Fuljenz's position as First Fidelity Reserve's gold expert is well-deserved due to his unrivaled expertise, market analysis capabilities, investment advice proficiency, industry insights, and rare coin expertise.

Clients can trust in his guidance as they navigate the intricate world of gold investing.

How to Buy Gold

There are several gold investment options available to you, each with its own advantages and considerations.

  1. Gold Eagles and government-issued coins: These coins are currently being issued by governments and offer lower mark-ups compared to rare coins. They come in various sizes, making them a more affordable option for investors.
  2. Rare gold coins: While these may have a higher cost per ounce of gold, their rarity guarantees demand from collectors and new investors. Even during market dips, there will always be buyers for certain collectibles.
  3. Gold IRAs: These retirement accounts offer the same advantages as other types of IRAs but include precious metals like gold. It eliminates the need to worry about storing physical metals while providing a hedge against financial uncertainties.

Factors affecting gold prices include recent events like the pandemic, inflation concerns, low-interest rates, stock market declines, and supply chain crises.

These conditions make investing in gold more attractive as it's seen as a hedge against inflation and uncertainty.

When buying gold coins from First Fidelity Reserve, you can expect secure storage options for your precious metals. They provide guidance on proper storage techniques to ensure your investment remains safe over time.

However, it's important to consider the risks associated with investing in gold. Market fluctuations can affect prices, and liquidity may vary depending on the type of coin or product purchased.

Conducting thorough research and due diligence is essential before making any investment decision.

First Fidelity Reserve offers various avenues for investing in gold—through government-issued coins or rare collectibles—and provides additional options like Gold IRAs for retirement planning convenience.

Understanding the factors influencing gold prices is crucial when considering this investment option, along with taking necessary precautions to store your assets securely.

Precious Metals IRA

Investing in a Precious Metals IRA can provide a secure and convenient way to safeguard your retirement savings with the potential for impressive gains. Diversifying your portfolio with precious metals, you can protect yourself against market volatility and inflation.

One of the advantages of a Precious Metals IRA is the tax benefits it offers. With a self-directed IRA, you have control over your investments and can enjoy tax-deferred growth on your retirement savings.

If you choose a Roth IRA, you may benefit from tax-free withdrawals in retirement.

When setting up a Precious Metals IRA, it's important to choose a reputable custodian that specializes in precious metals. First Fidelity Reserve is an experienced company that can guide you through the process and help tailor a strategy that fits your unique needs.

Keep in mind that there are investment limits for IRAs, including Precious Metals IRAs.

As of 2021, the annual contribution limit for individuals under the age of 50 is $6,000, while those over 50 can contribute up to $7,000 annually.

Investing in a Precious Metals IRA has several advantages such as tax benefits and diversification. It's crucial to work with a trusted custodian like First Fidelity Reserve to ensure your retirement savings are protected and potentially grow over time.

Consider exploring this option as part of your overall retirement strategy.

Why Gold Now?

Given the recent surge in inflation, declining stock market, and ongoing supply chain crisis, investing in gold has become an increasingly attractive option for safeguarding wealth and hedging against uncertainty.

Gold has long been considered a safe haven during times of economic turmoil. It offers several benefits that make it an appealing investment choice.

  • Firstly, gold has historically served as a hedge against inflation. 

When inflation rates rise, the value of paper currency tends to decline, while the price of gold typically increases. This makes gold an effective tool for preserving purchasing power.

  • Secondly, gold is known for its ability to provide stability to investment portfolios. 

Its price movements often have a low correlation with other asset classes like stocks and bonds. Diversifying your portfolio with gold, you can potentially reduce risk and increase overall returns.

  • Various factors influence the price of gold, including geopolitical tensions, economic indicators such as interest rates and GDP growth, and investor sentiment. 

The current global landscape characterized by uncertainty and potential conflicts makes gold even more appealing as a safe haven asset.

  • When comparing gold to other investment options like stocks or real estate, it is important to consider its unique qualities. 

Unlike stocks which carry company-specific risks or real estate which can be affected by local market conditions, gold's value is not tied to any particular entity or location.

Given the current economic circumstances marked by rising inflation rates, stock market volatility, and supply chain disruptions; investing in gold provides distinct advantages such as protection against inflation, portfolio diversification benefits due to low correlation with other assets classes; and its status as a safe haven asset during times of crisis.


Despite the mixed feedback from customers, it's evident that First Fidelity Reserve has maintained a strong reputation in the industry. They are praised for their excellent pricing, timely delivery, and valuable advice.

Customer satisfaction is reflected in the positive reviews highlighting the competitive pricing offered by First Fidelity Reserve. Their prices for gold and silver coins are often praised as some of the best in the market.

In addition to great pricing, customers appreciate the company's prompt delivery of purchases.

Timely fulfillment of orders is crucial when investing in precious metals, and First Fidelity Reserve ensures that clients receive their products swiftly.

While there have been negative comments regarding difficulties reaching specific individuals within the company, customer service overall has been rated positively.

Clients value the expertise and guidance provided by Dr. Mike Fuljenz, an esteemed expert in rare coins and precious metals. His knowledge contributes to investor confidence and helps clients make informed decisions.

Investment performance is another aspect where First Fidelity Reserve excels. The company focuses on historically important coins that have experienced significant price increases over time.

This strategy aligns with current market conditions and potential future trends.

In terms of overall customer experience, despite some negative reviews about high-pressure sales tactics, most clients appear satisfied with their interactions with First Fidelity Reserve.

The company's A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau further solidifies its reputation as a trustworthy investment partner.

When considering investing in gold or silver coins, customer satisfaction, pricing comparison, delivery speed, customer service quality, and investment performance should be key factors to evaluate different companies.

Is First Fidelity Reserve a Scam?

Worried about falling victim to a scam? Discover the truth about First Fidelity Reserve and why you can trust their reputation in the precious metals industry.

With over 20 years of experience and a continuously growing client base, it is unlikely that First Fidelity Reserve is a scam. However, it is essential to do your due diligence before investing your money with any company.

When examining customer experiences, it is important to consider both positive and negative reviews. While First Fidelity Reserve receives mostly positive reviews, some customers have mentioned difficulty reaching specific individuals and a high-pressure sales approach.

It is crucial to take these factors into account when making your investment decisions.

To evaluate the legitimacy of First Fidelity Reserve, industry comparisons can be helpful.

While there are potential risks associated with any investment, such as market fluctuations or economic downturns, First Fidelity Reserve has built a solid reputation in the industry by providing superlative service for over two decades.

They maintain an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and have transacted over $480 million while serving over 109,000 clients since 1988.

Although negative reviews exist, First Fidelity Reserve's long-standing presence in the industry and positive customer experiences indicate its legitimacy. Conducting thorough research and due diligence will help you make an informed decision about investing with them.


First Fidelity Reserve is a trusted and reputable company in the precious metals industry. 

With over 25 years of experience, they offer exceptional service and a wide range of gold and silver products, including rare coins.

Their focus on historically important coins and expert guidance from Dr. Mike Fuljenz make them a reliable choice for investors. And, their extensive inventory ensures timely order fulfillment, while their high prices for coins set them apart from competitors.

First Fidelity Reserve is a top choice for those interested in precious metals investment.

You can get a Complimentary Gold Investing Guide from the top gold investing company we recommend by clicking the button above. 

If you'd like a thorough review of the top 5 list, click here:

>>>Click HERE to Read Our List of the Best Gold IRA Companies in 2023.<<<

Or, visit First Fidelity Reserve below: